AMN News Archives

Review of Stella's latest release, Pony Girl

By Jack Sowers - 1/30/2002
Used by permission of the Shaft

"Stella" means "star" in some dead language - Latin, I think. The irony of a band in Athens taking that name is this: the chance of Stella becoming a recording "star" outside the confines of this locality is remote at best. Anybody remember what happened to the Snapdragons?

Stella's self-produced debut CD, Pony Girl, is a gem worthy of attention beyond this l'il hamlet, though. Too bad Stella's not likely to get any. If it was 20 years ago, when there was such a thing as "college rock," bands like Stella that strummed guitars and sang well had a real shot to get some national attention and even make a decent living.

But college rock's effect on the mainstream ended when the '80s did. After that, any band that wanted to reach "stardom" had a choice: sound like Nirvana or look like Matchbox 20.

Soundclips From Pony Girl by Stella
Elier Avenue
Crocodile Man
Just For Bert
This disk is for sale on the AMN. Click To Buy

Stella don't sound or look like either one. Laura Nadeau's rich vocals perfectly complement her mature yet playful songwriting. And she couldn't pick more suitable musicians in this town to play alongside in Dave Baer (bass) Catfish (the other stringed instruments) and Mark Hellenberg (drums and percussion). Stella's picked nice cover songs for half of the CD, too: their version of "I Am Alive" by local songwriter Bruce Dalzell is pretty enough to belong in a museum.

I'll root for them to become "stars," but my guess is that Stella will have to settle for entertaining the people who have the pleasure of hearing them in a CD player or in some Athens pub. Hopefully, that's good enough for them. Stellar.

prophet with tunnel vision
I am always amazed by people who dare to make statements such as "this band will not amount to anything outside Athens, " because historically speaking, its always these kinds of predictions that return with a vengance to bite the speaker in the ass.

Sir, I ask you. Are you a record reviewer of today? Or are you a prophet with tunnel vision, recently returned from a narrowly formulated future? You should stick close to the grooves at hand, and do your job as the AMN intended. Let the people decide Stella's future for themselves.

#1 by barb campagnola on Feb 05, 2002 11:00:00 PM

You missed my point
Good thing my 13-month statute of limitations on responses isn't up. What I wrote was that Stella was so good and the album so well-made it's a shame there isn't a widespread national market for it. That ratings-driven radio stations can't take a chance on a new, unfamiliar sound. I've played alongside Mark Hellenberg and I respect and enjoy Stella very much. I look forward to the day I hear them on NPR.

j

#2 by jack sowers on Feb 23, 2004 11:00:00 PM

Add a comment

All comments are moderated by a human. Off-topic posts are deleted upon submission. HTML and BBcode are not permitted.

human?

Web AMN

[ Previous Story ]  [ Next Story ]

Story Date
Photo Album: Liquor Store, The Mahonies at The Union 06/11/2009
Photo Album: Goodbye Goats, Sad Bastards at The Union 06/06/2009
Photo Album: Nordic Waste, Empirian at Smiling Skull Saloon 06/05/2009
Photo Album: The Revulvas, One Pretty Minute at Smiling Skull Saloon 05/29/2009
Photo Album: The Spikedrivers at Casa Cantina 05/28/2009
Photo Album: We March, Super Predator, Midwest Kid at Bruce Manor 05/23/2009
Photo Album: Red Army, Serious Snakes at 19 South 05/22/2009
Photo Album: Hennigan at 19 South 05/20/2009
Photo Album: the wallabeez at Jackie O's 05/20/2009
Photo Album: Hennigan at The Union 05/15/2009
Photo Album: The Revulvas at 19 South 05/09/2009
Photo Album: Amish Electric Chair, The Ghost of Asa Phelps at Smiling Skull Saloon 04/30/2009
Photo Album: Hotel War at 19 South 04/25/2009
Photo Album: Wooly Lemons, Hotel War at Jackie O's 04/24/2009
Photo Album: Birthday Suits at The Union 04/23/2009
Photo Album: The Crack Pipes, The Terrible Twos, The High Strung, The Blind Shake, Dropdead Sons, Night of Pleasure, Day Creeper, The Unholy Two, Submarine Spac 04/18/2009
Photo Album: Shilpa Ray and Her Happy Hookers, TV Ghost, El Jesus De Magico, The Neverevers, The Makebelieves, Sister Shuffle at The Union 04/17/2009
Photo Album: Times New Viking, Guinea Worms, Grafton, The Bygones, Dragline Bros, Necropolis, Ill Fits, Spooktober at The Union 04/16/2009
Photo Album: ACRN Staff, Casual Future, She Bears at The Union 04/04/2009
Photo Album: Wheels On Fire, The Makebelieves, We March at The Union 03/20/2009
Photo Album: Dragline Bros, Kaslo, Aquabear Peeps at The Union 03/07/2009
Photo Album: Phosphorescent, Order of the Spur, Civil War Generals, People at the Bruce Mannor at Bruce Manor 03/04/2009
Photo Album: Sun God, October Fist at The Union 02/25/2009
Photo Album: Drought, Front Royal at The Union 02/13/2009
Photo Album: Mister Got Heat, Earwig at Casa Cantina 02/07/2009
Photo Album: Necropolis at The Union 01/10/2009
Photo Album: Crucifixion Addiction at The Union 01/02/2009
Photo Album: Eva Destruction & the Ohio Country Outlaw Band at The Union 12/19/2008
Photo Album: Submarine Spaceship at The Union 12/05/2008
Photo Album: ACRN Battle of the Bands - The Vice Versas, Donner Party Dinner Party, Pulsating Anus, ACRN Judges at Smiling Skull Saloon 11/08/2008
View All 866 Stories
[ Expand ] Reviews
[ Expand ] Photo Albums
[ Expand ] Gig Guides
[ Expand ] Artists of the Month
[ Expand ] Interviews
[ Expand ] Opinions